The 5 Best Healthy Shirley Temple Sodas to Try

The 5 Best Healthy Shirley Temple Sodas to Try Now are, according to PureWow’s tasting roundup: Bloom Pop, Stiller’s Soda, Poppi, Olipop and Slice; Celsius earns an honorable mention. This guide summarizes the flavor takeaways, nutrition facts and where each better-for-you Shirley Temple stands in the mix.

What makes these versions “healthy” compared with a classic Shirley Temple?

PureWow’s feature explains that these brands aim for lower sugar and fewer calories than traditional mixers while keeping the cherry-and-ginger-lime profile of a Shirley Temple. The article notes nutrition facts for each product — for example, Bloom Pop clocks in at 20 calories and 3 grams of sugar, while the Poppi option is listed at 30 calories and 5 grams of sugar, figures reported in PureWow’s tasting roundup.

a neatly arranged trio of unbranded cans and a glass with pink soda and a maraschino-style cherry on a bright kitchen counter

Which soda tasted most like the classic Shirley Temple?

PureWow crowned Bloom Pop the winner for closest resemblance to a classic Shirley Temple, praising its “cherry-forward” flavor and light pomegranate-like tartness. The review lists Bloom Pop as the lowest-calorie winner at 20 calories and 3 grams of sugar per serving, and the writer said it matched the original’s aroma, taste and finish more closely than the other options.

Which options give an adult twist while staying better-for-you?

Stiller’s Soda is highlighted as a grown-up reimagining: PureWow describes it as lemon-lime forward with subtle dark cherry sweetness and made with real cane sugar, calling it a “delicious grown-up twist” rather than a carbon copy. The article reports Stiller’s at 30 calories and 7 grams of sugar, and it includes a note that Ben Stiller discussed his soda in an interview with Food & Beverage Magazine, which PureWow quotes.

a close-up scene of a single unbranded can beside a filled glass on a wooden table, a paper straw and a cherry garnish visible

Which better-for-you brands leaned closest to nostalgia versus innovation?

PureWow found a split between faithful and inventive takes. Poppi earned a spot near the top for delivering an unmistakably syrupy, Shirley-like sweetness — PureWow lists Poppi at 30 calories and 5 grams of sugar — while Olipop landed slightly lower because its Shirley-style drink leaned toward vanilla and cream-soda notes rather than a straight cherry mocktail. Slice was praised as light and tart, better for readers who prefer a less sweet sip; PureWow gives Slice 35 calories and 4 grams of sugar.

What about limited editions and honorable mentions?

PureWow included the CELSIUS Shirley Temple Spritz Vibe Winter Edition as an honorable mention, noting it has 15 calories and 0 grams of sugar and contains added vitamins and caffeine; the review called it light and “totally sippable” but flagged that it delivers a caffeine boost. The roundup treats limited-release flavors separately from the five ranked sodas because availability and formula can vary by season.

How should you pick the best healthy Shirley Temple for your taste?

If you want the truest throwback, PureWow recommends Bloom Pop first and Poppi second for strong cherry and grenadine-like notes. If you prefer a more nuanced or grown-up soda, Stiller’s or Olipop may suit you. For lower sweetness with more citrus bite, Slice is the choice PureWow recommends.

Where possible, PureWow lists typical retail prices for comparison: many of these cans sell in 12-packs in the $23–$30 range depending on brand and retailer. The PureWow guide includes those price points alongside nutrition facts to help readers weigh cost versus flavor and nutrition.

Where to read the full tasting notes and buy these sodas?

PureWow’s tasting roundup, written by Catrina Yohay, contains the full reviews, photos and purchasing notes that informed this guide. The article is the source for the nutrition figures and the author’s tasting impressions cited here.

Related reading on this site: explore seasonal mixers in The 28 Best Fall Cocktails to Try This Autumn and dessert pairings for holiday menus in 12 Thanksgiving Desserts That Aren’t Pie.

Leave a Comment

Share to...