12 Thanksgiving Desserts That Aren’t Pie

Sally’s Baking Addiction published a roundup titled “12 Thanksgiving Desserts That Aren’t Pie” on November 18, 2026, naming a dozen seasonal alternatives to the usual pies, from cakes to make-ahead no-bake sweets, according to the site.

The post says the collection includes crowd-pleasers such as Cornbread Cookies, a Pumpkin Roll, a brown-sugar Pecan Pie Cheesecake, and make-ahead options like tiramisu and mini cheesecakes that travel well, per Sally’s Baking Addiction.

Which desserts does Sally recommend instead of pie?

The site lists twelve concrete recipes readers can use in place of pie: Cornbread Cookies with Salted Honey Buttercream; Pumpkin Roll; Pecan Pie Cheesecake; Cranberry Orange Bundt Cake; Super Moist Spice Cake; Maple Baked Pears; Snickerdoodle Blondies; Pumpkin Cream Cheese Bundt Cake; Cinnamon Swirl Cheesecake; Chocolate-Covered Date & Almond Truffles; Tiramisu; Easy Apple Cake; and Mini Cheesecakes, all presented with recipe links on the same page.

close-up of a plate of assorted Thanksgiving desserts (slices of Bundt cake, small cheesecake squares, and cookie bars) arranged on a wooden table, no identifiable people, no brand or text

Which of these travel or store well ahead of the holiday?

Sally notes that several picks are make-ahead friendly: tiramisu and mini cheesecakes are described as “best when made ahead,” and cookies or bars like snickerdoodle blondies are singled out as items that “keep well for several days and can be frozen.”

That practical guidance is part of the post’s planning advice for a busy Thanksgiving kitchen and the reason many home cooks choose non-pie desserts when they need extra prep flexibility.

How can you choose the right non-pie dessert for your menu?

Match the dessert’s weight and flavor to the rest of your meal: Sally recommends lighter options such as maple baked pears for a post-feast palate cleanser, and richer choices like cinnamon swirl cheesecake or pecan pie cheesecake when you want an indulgent finale.

If serving a large group, she suggests sheet cakes or Bundt cakes for easy slicing; for small gatherings or portable desserts, the post highlights cookies, bars, and mini cheesecakes.

a well-lit single cranberry orange Bundt cake on a neutral platter, a slice removed to show crumb and glaze, no people or branding

Where to find the recipes and further Thanksgiving baking resources?

All recipes named in the roundup are hosted on Sally’s Baking Addiction, which also links to related collections such as 40+ Thanksgiving pie recipes and fall cake ideas, the post explains. Those linked collections offer additional riffs and sizing tips for feeding different group sizes.

For side-dish planning to match a non-pie dessert spread, see the site’s guidance on Thanksgiving sides; for make-ahead dessert bars and pies, the site offers step-by-step recipes and transport tips that readers can follow.

What should you make based on timing and crowd size?

For a largely make-ahead plan, the post emphasizes desserts that improve after resting—tiramisu and many cheesecakes—or handheld treats like cookies and bars for easy portioning. For a show-stopping centerpiece that still isn’t pie, Sally recommends a Bundt or layered spice cake.

Her practical note: use covered pans for transport and choose recipes that match the time you have on the calendar.

Where to read the full list?

You can read the complete roundup on Sally’s Baking Addiction; the site published the piece on November 18, 2026, and it includes direct links to each recipe and additional Thanksgiving baking resources, according to the article’s page metadata.

If you want matching sides or other make-ahead items to pair with a non-pie dessert, check this site’s 40+ Thanksgiving Side Dishes to Round Out Your Menu, a compact list of crowd-pleasing sides. For a seasonal dessert bar idea, see How to make Maple Sweet Potato Pie Bars, and for a warm-fruit option, consider this Spiced Cranberry Cherry Cobbler recipe.

Planning tip: pick one showstopper (Bundt or layered cake) and one portable option (cookies or bars) so guests can choose without overfilling a single dessert station.

Leave a Comment

Share to...