Where to Order Thanksgiving Dinner and Catering in NYC

If you want to skip cooking this year, order your Thanksgiving dinner and catering in NYC from restaurants, bakeries and markets listed by PureWow — they recommend spots including Citarella for full holiday meals and lots of pick-up options.

Where can you place a full Thanksgiving meal order?

PureWow’s roundup of “Where to Order Thanksgiving Dinner and Catering in NYC” lists markets, bakeries and restaurants that will prepare complete holiday meals for pick-up or local delivery, and notes options for sides and desserts so you can avoid the kitchen entirely.

For example, PureWow names Citarella as a gourmet market offering an extensive Thanksgiving menu, and it reports Citarella asks customers to place orders “no later than 4 p.m. Friday, Nov. 20 for pick-up or local delivery on Wednesday, Nov. 25.”

Assorted ready-to-heat holiday platters on a wooden counter, unlabeled packaging and pie boxes visible

When must you place orders to guarantee pick-up?

Different vendors set different deadlines; PureWow highlights merchant-specific cutoffs, and Zabar’s order information appears in search listings showing an order deadline of Sunday, Nov. 23 with pickup on Wednesday, Nov. 26, so check each shop’s stated deadline before you commit.

Because many shops cap capacity, PureWow warns to order early to avoid sell-outs and to confirm whether pick-up is the day before Thanksgiving or on Wednesday.

What should you consider when choosing a caterer or market?

Decide whether you want a fully cooked turkey and trimmings, just sides and desserts, or a mix of chef-prepared entrees and DIY finishing steps. PureWow’s guide groups options by type — markets that sell roasted turkeys, bakeries for pies and restaurants offering multi-course heat-and-serve menus — so you can mix vendors.

If you still want some homemade touches, PureWow suggests adding easy appetizers; our internal guide to 40+ Thanksgiving Side Dishes can help you pick simple sides to complement a store-bought main.

Hands arranging small appetizer plates on a kitchen island, figs and toothpicks visible but no faces or logos

How do pick-up logistics usually work?

Vendors typically specify a narrow pick-up window in the days before Thanksgiving and may offer local delivery; PureWow’s list notes timing differences between shops and urges customers to confirm pickup times when ordering.

Also check whether a vendor limits how many orders it accepts, and whether reheating instructions are included so you can serve everything hot without last-minute fuss.

Which vendors are good for adding desserts or party snacks?

PureWow groups bakeries and specialty shops as sources for pies and sweet finishes, and suggests pairing a purchased main with bakery desserts or market sides; you can also consult our Trader Joe’s roundup for show-stopping packaged sides and drinks to round out the table (Trader Joe’s show-stopping Thanksgiving foods and drinks).

Ordering a mix of market mains and bakery desserts is a fast way to get a complete spread while keeping vintage family favorites on the side.

Quick checklist before you hit “place order”

  • Confirm the vendor’s order deadline and reserve a pickup time.
  • Check whether the menu serves the right number of guests and whether portions are adjustable.
  • Ask if reheating or carving is required and whether the vendor supplies instructions.
  • Verify cancellation or refund policies if your headcount changes.
  • Plan at least one easy homemade item or appetizer to personalize the meal.

Use PureWow’s curated list as a starting point and call the shop to confirm deadlines and pickup windows before you finalize payment.

Good luck — and enjoy a more relaxing Turkey Day without spending it over the stove.

Attribution

This page uses reporting assembled by PureWow’s feature “Where to Order Thanksgiving Dinner and Catering in NYC.” Zabar’s order details were visible in current vendor listings for Thanksgiving pickup windows.

Leave a Comment

Share to...