Dan Pelosi‘s Dark ’n’ Stormy Cookies are a rum- and ginger-forward holiday cookie from The New York Times Cooking that takes 1 hour 55 minutes total and has a 5-star average from 1,461 ratings. This recipe yields 24 cookies and finishes with a lime-and-rum glaze for tart contrast.
What makes these cookies Dark ’n’ Stormy?
The recipe, published on The New York Times Cooking, adapts the Dark ’n’ Stormy cocktail by soaking crystallized ginger in dark rum, folding candied ginger into a molasses-and-spice dough, and adding a pinch of cayenne for heat. The glaze combines powdered sugar, dark rum and lime juice to echo the drink’s bright finish, according to The New York Times Cooking page.
15 Pumpkin Desserts That’ll Beat Pumpkin Pie
The Best Halloween Candy of All Time — Super‑Scientifically Ranked

How long and how many?
The recipe lists a total time of 1 hour 55 minutes: about 15 minutes prep and 1 hour 40 minutes including cooling, and it makes 24 cookies. The instructions say to bake the cookies for exactly 12 minutes, then cool on the tray for 5 minutes before transferring to a rack and dipping the faces in glaze.
Key ingredients and simple swaps
Core ingredients named by The New York Times Cooking include all-purpose flour, dark brown sugar, unsalted butter, molasses, eggs, crystallized ginger soaked briefly in dark rum, and a spice mix of ground ginger, cinnamon, cloves and cayenne. For the glaze, the recipe uses powdered sugar, dark rum and lime juice, finished with lime zest. The recipe also notes tossing rolled dough in granulated sugar before baking for a crackled exterior.

Tips from cooks who tried it
Readers on the recipe page report the cookies come out soft and chewy with strong ginger and lime notes; one comment recommends chilling sticky dough before scooping and rolling to make handling easier. The New York Times Cooking comments thread also suggests smaller scoops and a slightly shorter bake time for more modest cookie sizes.
Where this recipe appeared and why it matters
The cookie was one of the New York Times Cooking Cookie Week recipes, listed among seven holiday cookies for 2025. The inclusion highlights the recipe’s seasonal appeal and the Times’ framing of the cookie as a party-ready, spice-forward seasonal treat.
Related recipes on this site include a mint chocolate chip cookie and an easy peanut brown-butter cookie if you want another holiday bake to pair on a platter: Mint Chocolate Chip Cookies and Peanut brown-butter cookies.

Samuel Knox writes about desserts with a focus on comfort and simplicity. His recipes highlight homemade sweets that are easy to prepare and meant to be shared.








