Mint Chocolate Chip Cookies Eric Kim: recipe, time and ratings

The New York Times recipe for Mint Chocolate Chip Cookies (often discussed with contributor Eric Kim in the comments) lists a total time of 1 hour 15 minutes, plus cooling and shows a 5‑star average from 1,221 ratings, according to the recipe page.

This guide explains what those numbers mean, what the recipe requires, how the mint topping is made, and quick tips to finish the cookies in a home kitchen. It uses the NYT recipe as the source for timing, yield and user ratings.

What the recipe yields and how long it takes

The New York Times recipe yields about 18 pieces from a 9‑inch square pan and gives a prep time of 5 minutes with a cook time that contributes to the 1 hour 15 minutes total, plus the time the pan needs to cool in order to set the topping.

The site’s totals are explicit: the recipe page lists “Total Time 1 hour 15 minutes, plus cooling” and displays “5 out of 5, 1,221 user ratings.”

A well-lit 9-inch square baking pan of cooled mint‑topped cookie bark on parchment, cut into long irregular pieces, an offset spatula nearby

Ingredients at a glance

The cookie base is a simple sugar‑cookie style dough made without a mixer: butter, powdered sugar, an egg white, peppermint and vanilla extracts, salt and all‑purpose flour. The topping combines melted white chocolate thinned with extra‑virgin olive oil, peppermint extract and a blue‑green tint, finished with finely chopped bittersweet dark chocolate.

The NYT ingredient list and amounts are provided on the recipe page and note that the recipe recommends chilling the pan until the white chocolate topping is just set before cutting.

Close crop of minty white chocolate spread across a cooled cookie slab, flecked with dark chocolate shavings and a small bowl of chopped bittersweet chocolate beside it

How the method affects timing

Most of the 1 hour 15 minutes labeled on the page comes from a short bake (25–30 minutes) followed by cooling in the pan for about 1 hour so the slab firms up before topping and slicing. The white‑chocolate topping also needs brief chilling to set.

Because the base is spread in a pan rather than piped cookies, hands‑on time is short and the recipe is useful when you want a quick assembly and slice approach rather than forming individual rounds.

Common tweaks and reviewer notes

Readers on the NYT page share practical changes: some used a larger pan for thinner bars, added mini chocolate chips to the base, or used a whole egg for a chewier texture. One commenter notes refrigeration extends freshness to a week and freezing to a month.

The recipe author and commenters discuss how a little more olive oil can rescue seized white chocolate; the recipe itself suggests adding more oil if the white chocolate firms while melting.

Why bakers like this version

The NYT writeup highlights that peppermint extract gives an “icy cooling effect” and that the combination of a crisp‑tender base with minty white chocolate and dark chocolate shavings recreates the mint chip ice‑cream flavor in cookie form. That flavor profile and the easy pan method help explain the high user rating shown on the page.

Quick checklist before you bake

  1. Preheat your oven to 325°F and grease a 9‑inch square pan with parchment overhang.
  2. Mix butter and powdered sugar by hand, then whisk in egg white and extracts before folding in flour.
  3. Bake 25–30 minutes until lightly golden; cool in pan about 1 hour before topping.
  4. Melt white chocolate and thin with olive oil, spread and top with chopped dark chocolate, then chill until set and slice into irregular pieces.

If you want more cookie ideas that use a short hands‑on method, see the site’s Peanut brown‑butter cookies recipe or the simple Three‑Ingredient Peanut Butter Cookies.

What to do next

Follow the NYT recipe’s ingredient amounts and timing for the same results, allow the recommended cooling time so the topping sets cleanly, and consider the commenters’ tweaks if you want more chew or an extended yield. The NYT recipe page is the place to save or print the full ingredient list and step‑by‑step instructions.

Recipe details, times and the rating are taken from the New York Times Cooking recipe page for “Mint Chocolate Chip Cookies.”

Leave a Comment

Share to...